• Home
  • Archives
  • Profile
  • Subscribe

The Probate Lawyer Blog

Famous Fortune Fights! by Andy & Danielle Mayoras

Home Archives Profile Subscribe

Guardianship and Conservatorship Disputes

What do you do when you discover an invalid Power of Attorney or Patient Advocate Designation? What happens when an Attorney-in-Fact is not acting in the best interests of your vulnerable loved one? How do you help your parent with Alzheimer’s or dementia when he or she refuses to acknowledge needing help, even when it is obvious to you that the situation is becoming dangerous?CFPL logo

In any of these cases, the only safe way to protect a vulnerable adult is through guardianship and/or conservatorship proceedings.

Both proceedings are handled in probate court and involve someone asking for a decision-maker to be appointed because the person in need of protection is unable to make or communicate informed decisions. Guardians make medical, placement and other decisions, while Conservators handle the finances. One person often serves in both roles at the same time, but courts can appoint different people as well.

First, what if your parent, or someone else in the family, disagrees that a guardian or conservator is necessary? Judges will examine whatever records you can present them with, including medical and financial records, as well as listen to family members and others who give testimony about why the person needs help making decisions. Sometimes courts will even appoint an independent physician to examine the person and file a written report.

Judges do not take this decision lightly; they have to find clear and convincing evidence to take away someone’s legal right to make their own decisions. But Judges do worry about whether the person is making safe choices. The best interest of the vulnerable person is most important. Often, whether a guardian or conservator is needed is the easy part.

Who gets appointed in these roles? Typically, it is a family member or other loved one of the person to be protected, or ward. And, the ward’s choice does matter! This is especially true for someone with early stages Alzheimer’s or dementia who still retains some decision-making ability but requires assistance. Even an incompetent person’s choice will carry great weight if it was expressed through a Power of Attorney or Patient Advocate signed when the person was still competent.

In fact, Michigan law requires probate judges to honor the ward’s preference in most cases, and if not, the judge must follow a list of people required by statute. This list includes a spouse, adult child, or other relative, and certain others (in that order). A person can only be skipped over for someone lower on the list of priorities only if he or she is unwilling or unsuitable to serve.

This choice is not set in stone however. Probate judges do have a large amount of discretion in making this important choice, and will usually decide based on what is in the best interests of the protected person.

How does the judge decide when the family fights about who is most suitable? Often siblings both feel they would be the best choice. Second marriages present significant difficulties when the spouse of the incompetent person does not get along well with the children from the prior marriage. Sometimes, there is even a fight between the ward and his or her own children.

Because probate judges make the decision, and their choices are almost never overturned by appellate judges, family members vying for appointment must do everything they can to convince the judge that they are most suitable, and that their opponent is not suitable. This process is not fun for anyone who participates, but sometimes is necessary. Compromise is usually the best solution, but when it simply is not possible, then the judge will decide. Sometimes the decision is one that neither side is happy with – such as the selection of an outsider, such as an independent attorney or guardianship company.

The best way to protect yourself – and more important, protect your elderly loved one – is to have an experienced probate litigation attorney represent you in court. Knowing what to say, and how to present your case in the best light to the particular judge assigned, can make all the difference. Judges are human beings too; experienced attorneys who know the tendencies of your particular judge are a great benefit.

Once the Guardian and/or Conservator is appointed, the person or persons appointed serve with similar fiduciary obligations as an Attorney-in-Fact. Again, they have the strictest of duties to act in the best interests of the ward they are required to protect.

Unlike in a Power-of-Attorney situation, they have the additional requirement of reporting to the probate court. Each year, every guardian and conservator must file a detailed report, so that the probate court can make sure that the ward is properly protected. Probate courts often also require bonds to be posted when the protected person has significant assets.

Guardians and Conservators are also subject to removal petitions, where someone asks the court to replace them or terminate the guardianship/conservatorship altogether. These can be filed by anyone interested in the ward’s welfare. In fact, even the protected person can seek this relief by writing a simple letter to the judge.

Certainly, no one should choose to initiate a guardianship or conservatorship proceeding unless they have no other good choice. But when diplomacy has failed, or when a loved one’s Alzheimer’s, dementia or other condition causes them to be too stubborn to admit that they need help making decisions, this path is the only safe choice. With an experienced attorney guiding the family, protective proceedings through probate court help many people sleep at night knowing their loved one is safe.

The Center for Probate Litigation, located in metro Detroit Michigan, can help with guardianship and conservatorship disputes.  Call them at 248-641-7070 for a free consultation.  This article is not intended to substitute for proper legal advice and is based entirely on Michigan laws.  While laws in this area do have similarities from state to state, laws do vary from time to time.  Anyone facing these issues is encouraged to find an attorney experienced in handling disputes of this nature.

By: Andrew Mayoras

My Photo

Trial & Heirs on Amazon

  • Danielle and Andy Mayoras: Trial & Heirs:  Famous Fortune Fights!: ... And what you can learn from celebrity errors (2nd edition)

    Danielle and Andy Mayoras: Trial & Heirs: Famous Fortune Fights!: ... And what you can learn from celebrity errors (2nd edition)

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Our Michigan Law Firm

  • TypePad

CALL FOR A FREE CONSULTATION:

  • 248-641-7070
    For legal issues in Michigan involving probate, litigation, estate planning, elder law, and more!
  • 1-888-99 HEIRS (4-3477)
    For help in other states (initial consultation may require a modest fee for some states).

Search

Pages

  • Welcome / What is "Probate Litigation"?
  • A Probate Lawyer's View On Solving Legal Problems
  • Michigan Contested Probate Attorney -- What I Do
  • So what's so interesting about probate litigation cases?
  • Challenging a Power of Attorney or Patient Advocate Designation
  • Guardianship and Conservatorship Disputes
  • Theft and Exploitation of Assets
  • Legal Contests Involving Wills, Trusts, and Joint Accounts
  • Warning Signs of Financial Abuse
  • Personal Injury Attorneys Helping Michigan Families
  • Michigan seniors now have a better chioce - stay at home!

Categories

  • Aaron Spelling (1)
  • Actors (94)
  • Administrator Duties (34)
  • Al Davis (1)
  • Alzheimer's Disease (28)
  • Amanda Bynes (3)
  • Amy Winehouse (4)
  • Andrew Mayoras (53)
  • Anna Nicole Smith (14)
  • Annuities (2)
  • Archie Comics (1)
  • Aretha Franklin (1)
  • Arturo Gatti (2)
  • Athletes (27)
  • Avicii (1)
  • B.B. King (2)
  • Barnes art collection (3)
  • Bernard Madoff (2)
  • Bo Schembechler (1)
  • Bob Marley (3)
  • Bobby Fischer (1)
  • Britney Spears (12)
  • Brittany Murphy (1)
  • Brooke Astor (10)
  • Casey Kasem (7)
  • Celebrities (244)
  • Celebrity Legacies (22)
  • Charitable Planning (2)
  • Charles Manson (1)
  • Charlie Sheen (2)
  • Chris Kyle (1)
  • Competency Disputes (67)
  • Conservatorship (44)
  • Creditor claims (10)
  • Danielle Mayoras (43)
  • David Bowie (1)
  • Davy Jones (1)
  • Dementia (46)
  • Dennis Hopper (11)
  • divorce (5)
  • Donald Sterling (1)
  • Doris Duke (1)
  • Edward Kennedy (2)
  • Elder Law (24)
  • Elizabeth Taylor (3)
  • Elvis Presley (14)
  • Ernie Banks (1)
  • Estate Planning (183)
  • Estate tax (8)
  • Exploitation (65)
  • Family Fortunes (101)
  • Farrah Fawcett (10)
  • Forgery (10)
  • Fortune Fights (4)
  • Fraud (39)
  • Funeral and Burial (9)
  • Gary Coleman (10)
  • Gay Marriage (1)
  • Gay Rights (1)
  • Gene Wilder (1)
  • George Michael (1)
  • George Steinbrenner (2)
  • Geronimo (1)
  • Gifts (10)
  • Guardianship (55)
  • Hugh Hefner (1)
  • Huguette Clark (2)
  • humor (2)
  • Ike Turner (2)
  • International Stories (37)
  • James Brown (9)
  • James Dean (1)
  • James Gandolfini (2)
  • Jenni Rivera (1)
  • Jim Morrison (1)
  • Joan Rivers (4)
  • Joey Bishop (1)
  • John Lennon (1)
  • John Wayne (1)
  • Johnny Depp (2)
  • Joint Ownership (7)
  • Kaley Cuoco (2)
  • Kobe Bryant (1)
  • Kurt Cobain (1)
  • L'Oreal (4)
  • Lawsuits (239)
  • Lee Marvin (1)
  • Legendary Figures (40)
  • Leona Helmsley (4)
  • Life Insurance (12)
  • Liliane Bettencourt (4)
  • Lisa Marie Presley (1)
  • Lou Reed (2)
  • Lucille Ball (1)
  • Luke Perry (1)
  • Madonna (1)
  • Malcolm X (1)
  • Marilyn Monroe (2)
  • Mark Zuckerberg (1)
  • Marlon Brando (8)
  • Martin Luther King, Jr. (5)
  • Marvin Gaye (1)
  • Melvin Simon (2)
  • Michael Crichton (4)
  • Michael Jackson (31)
  • Mick Jagger (2)
  • Mickey Rooney (3)
  • Muhammad Ali (1)
  • Musicians (101)
  • National Enquirer (1)
  • Nelson Mandela (1)
  • Nina Wang (5)
  • Octo-Mom (1)
  • Paul Newman (1)
  • Paul Walker (2)
  • Personal Injury (9)
  • Peter Falk (4)
  • Philip Seymour Hoffman (3)
  • Phoebe Hearst Cooke (3)
  • Power of Attorney (20)
  • Prince (3)
  • Princess Diana (1)
  • Probate Court (186)
  • Reese Witherspoon (1)
  • Richard Pryor (1)
  • Robin Williams (3)
  • Ron Perelman (3)
  • Rosa Parks (3)
  • Russell Armstrong (1)
  • Sam Simon (1)
  • Sofia Vergara (3)
  • Stan Lee (1)
  • Steve Jobs (1)
  • Steve McNair (6)
  • Stieg Larsson (2)
  • Succession Planning (12)
  • Superman (1)
  • The Gipper (2)
  • Tom Benson (1)
  • Tom Carvel Estate (1)
  • Tom Clancy (2)
  • Tony Curtis (2)
  • Trial & Heirs (59)
  • Trustee Duties (26)
  • Trusts (170)
  • Tupac Shakur (3)
  • Undue influence (56)
  • Walt Disney (1)
  • Wang Yung-ching (1)
  • Wesley Snipes (3)
  • Whitney Houston (12)
  • Will Contest (58)
  • William Davidson (3)
  • William Randolph Hearst family (3)
  • Wills (189)
  • Zsa Zsa Gabor (5)
See More
View Andrew Mayoras's profile on LinkedIn
See how we're connected

Twitter Updates

    follow me on Twitter

    Legal Disclaimer

    • Legal Disclaimer
      Nothing in this blog should be relied on as legal advice. The information contained herein does not create an attorney/client relationship. The articles posted are intended for entertainment and general information purposes only. Laws vary state by state. Anyone seeking legal advice for a specific situation should consult a qualified probate lawyer or similar qualified professional in the appropriate state.
    Add to Technorati Favorites

    About

    Bookmark and Share

    Trial & Heirs

    • TypePad

    Other Links of Interest

    • Trial & Heirs: Famous Fortune Fights!
    • My Justia Profile
    • The Center For Special Needs Planning
    • Working Caregiver Initiative

    Other Probate Related Blogs

    • Wills, Trusts and Estates Prof Blog
    • Florida Probate and Trust Litigation Blog
    • Ohio Estate Planning, Trust & Probate Law
    • Pennsylvania Fiduciary Litigation Blog
    • The Perfect Estate Plan (Florida)
    • The North Carolina Estate Planning Blog
    • Florida Estate Planning Lawyer Blog
    • Observations of a Boston Lawyer
    • Texas Probate Litigation
    • Georgia Wills, Trusts and Estate Planning Blog
    • San Diego California Probate Lawyer
    • The Probate.net Blog (Texas)
    • Estate Planning & Asset Protection (California)
    • Los Angeles Trust and Probate Blog
    • Mass. Estate Planning and Elder Law Blog
    • Elder and Disability Advocate Blog
    • Living Trust Network
    • North Carolina Wills and Trusts Blog
    • South Carolina Probate Lawyer Blog
    • Your Texas Estate Plan Blog
    • Houston Estate Attorney Blog
    • The Probate Lawyer by Fortenberry Legal
    • Arkansas Wealth Wars

    Other legal blogs

    • Ciciliano Law Blog (Nevada Family Law)
    • Ohio Law Blog
    • Legal Administration Blog
    • Law Offices of Joseph C. Markowitz (California)
    • North Carolina Law Life
    • A Paralegal's Blog (Mass.)
    • NY Medical Malpractice & Personal Injury Trial Lawyer Blog
    • Peter Berlin Blog (California Criminal Defense)
    • Indiana Civil & Business Lawyer
    • The LinkenIn Lawyer Blog (Mass.)
    • Ohio Employment, Labor and Workers Compensation Law Blog
    • The Real Estate Spot Blog (Utah/Washington)
    • The Business Law Spot Blog (Utah/Washington)
    • Iowa Dirt Lawyer Blog (Real Estate)
    • Massachusetts Lawyer Blog
    • Michigan Lawyer's Weekly
    • Virginia criminal law firm
    • The Complete Lawyer Blog

    Notice

    • Copyright 2008-2014 Trial & Heirs. All rights reserved.

     Subscribe in a reader

    Recent Comments

    • Rexx on Wesley Snipes and the Pure Trust scam
    • Carma Lovely on Eliza Presley's Lawsuit Is Back In Court
    • Find US Lawyers on Judges orders conservatorship over Peter Falk
    • Nikola Webster on Eliza Presley case is delayed
    • Houston probate attorney on Luke Perry Protected His Children With Estate Planning
    • marie on Monkey Business Surrounding Davy Jones Estate
    • Darren Sharrocks on Eliza Presley's Lawsuit Is Back In Court
    • Darren Sharrocks on Eliza Presley's Lawsuit Is Back In Court
    • Marcia Southwick on Federal guardianship abuse probe raises major concerns
    • Peter Heise on Avicii Died Without A Will But Illustrated An Important Lesson

    Recent Posts

    • Luke Perry Protected His Children With Estate Planning
    • Madonna Fortune Fights: The Material Girl Perservered Through Many Court Battles
    • No Stranger To Legal Battles, Robin Williams Protected His Family From A Similar Fate After His Deat
    • Casey Kasem Fortune Fight: Is A Family Member Responsible For The Radio Icon's Death?
    • Johnny Depp Is Still Feuding With Amber Heard. Who Is Telling The Truth?
    • Avicii Died Without A Will But Illustrated An Important Lesson
    • Aretha Franklin Had No Will or Trust, But The Family Rallied Together To Protect Her Legacy
    • Stan Lee Needs Savings, Not By A Superhero, But By A Conservator
    • Richard Pryor & Marlon Brando Rumor Rekindles Bitter Feud Over Pryor's Estate
    • Inside The Battle Raging Over The Estate of Charles Manson

    Archives

    • March 2019
    • February 2019
    • January 2019
    • August 2018
    • July 2018
    • March 2018
    • January 2018
    • November 2017
    • October 2017
    • August 2017
    • The Probate Lawyer Blog •
    • Powered by Typepad
    Top